Genre
"Cat in the Rain" is an archetype
of its genre, the short story. It is brief and relies more on suggestion than
actual words, and therefore, it carries multiple meanings. Hemingway is quite
economical with descriptions and dialogues.
Initial Situation
First there is a description of
the environment in good weather, which means spring or summer, then a
description of the momentary situation in the rain. This description creates
an atmosphere that is sad, cold and unfriendly. To create this atmosphere Hemingway
uses words such as "empty" or "the motorcars were gone".
Later on, by looking at the relationship of the two Americans, you can see
that this description was a foreshadowing of the state of the couple´s
relationship: First it was nice, the spring-time of their love, and now there
is only rain, their relationship got cold and unfriendly.
The couple stuck in their room. The description of
the view from the window suggests that the woman has spent a lot of time
looking at it. While she looked listlessly on the view outside her husband
lay on bed absorbed in his book. The wife is an extrovert focused on lived
life while her husband is focused on the internal world of books and ideas.
Conflict
Seeing the cat gives the
wife a reason to move. Her dismissal of her husband's half-hearted offer to
go down to fetch the cat suggests her dissatisfaction with him.
Complication
Downstairs, the wife
encounters the hotelkeeper whom she refers to by the more dignified Italian
term, “padrone”. When she looks under the table, however, the cat isn't
there.
Suspense
The padrone gives the
wife a sense of importance. The wife is strongly affected.
Climax
After returning to the
room without the cat the wife makes a list of the things she wants: long
hair, a cat on her lap, her own silver, candles, springtime. Her husband,
George, fed up, tells her to shut up and find something to read. The sentence that she wants it to be spring again
stands for her huge wish for a new spring in her relationship
Denouement
The wife doesn't react to
her husband’s scolding; instead, she looks out the window as the evening
darkens around her. As she cannot have "long hair or any fun," she
states that she wants a cat.
Conclusion
The room and the couple
go back to the same state at the beginning of the story. It is at this point
the hotel maid knocks on the door and announces that the padrone has sent a
cat for "the signora." It's a gesture of thoughtfulness.
A small coastal village
in Italy on a rainy day soon after the end of WWI. The couple in the story is
staying at an upscale sea-side hotel and their room is located on the second
floor facing the sea – this implies that the two people are well-off, and
therefore, the reason for the palpable tension that permeates the story
cannot be due to financial worries. The impact of WWI or the Great War, as it
was called, is strongly felt throughout the story. WWI wiped out nearly an
entire generation of young men in Europe and left the landscape as well as
the minds of people deeply scarred. We are told that there is a War Monument
in the middle of the town square. Such monuments are quite common in Europe.
They represent lost hope for the near-and-dear of those hundreds of thousands
who have fallen as well for the country at large. At the end of the war two
groups remained: those who did not join the war and the emotionally and
physically scared veterans. I have the impression that George belonged to the
former category as implied by the inertia he displays throughout the story.
We
are told that people from all over Italy come to pay their respects to the
War Monument in the public garden. It's one of the things the wife sees from
her perch at the window. We are also told that a lot of people come there to
paint the sea-side view. The
juxtaposition of the people painting the seaside view and those who come to
pay respects to the WM in the opening paragraph points at the complexity of
emotions experienced by people after the war came to an end. It was time of
celebration as well as of sorrow. While some picked up the threads of their
lives and tried to move on beyond satisfying their basic needs, some were trapped
in the memories of their losses and pains experienced during the war.
Hemingway sets the story on a
rainy day. No one can go out on such a day – a sense of imprisonment/ entrapment
and an acute disappointment hangs heavily in the air. People come to a
sea-side resort to frolic out in the sun and not to gaze out of a closed
window.
What
parallels can you draw between the rainy day described in the short story and
the state of the marriage of the American couple?
The third person narrator
relates the story using basic sentences, mostly statements. This encourages
the reader to believe that the narrator is being strictly factual about the
event he is narrating and that he has no personal opinions or biases. However,
a closer reading implies that the narrator allocates more ‘space’ to what the
wife is doing than to any other character, especially her husband George.
Yet, in his defense one can say that George does very little to write about
throughout the story.
The reader’s view of the hotel
owner depends heavily on what the wife feels about how she is being treated
by him. The third person narrator conveys her feelings, which she herself
cannot fully articulate in speech. By using an omniscient narrator, Hemingway
is able to convey both conscious as well as unconscious/ unarticulated
thoughts of the characters.
The tone is controlled to the
point of terseness. The husband and wife seem to have very different
temperaments and are dissatisfied with one another. However, they don't talk
about it. As Blake in his poem “The Poison Tree” had very successfully
illustrated unexpressed dissatisfaction/anger festers and brings about ruin. Their
trip to Italy could have been a last ditch effort to save their floundering marriage.
However, their unexpressed differences seem insurmountable. Consequently,
instead of the new surroundings pushing them towards each other, it seems to
widen the emotional chasm between them. In such a situation being trapped in
a hotel room on a rainy day in a foreign country with only each other for
company would bring out the very worst in each other as implied by the terse
exchanges between the two. Hemingway's sentences, both in the dialogues and
descriptions, are clipped/terse/ minimalistic to the point of being rude.
The actions and the dialogues centre
on a cat in the rain. However, why an American wife on a holiday in Italy with
her husband should take a particular interest in a wet cat hiding under a
table is a question that begs an answer. One might ask whether she sees any
parallels between her own situation, trapped in a hotel in a foreign country on
a rainy day with a neglectful husband, that makes her sympathize with the
cat?
The title "Cat in the
Rain" as opposed to" The Cat in the Rain" points at the
possibility of any number of people/animals experiencing such a situation. The
four words in the title are all monosyllabic words which are deceptively
simple.
Cat:
The absence of the articles "the" or "a" in the title
makes the it sound like the title of a painting which points at the
possibility of Hemingway trying to paint a word study of a couple of restless
dissatisfied American tourist on a rainy day in an Italian sea-side village.
Cats for the most part, are calm and collected. But a wet cat anything but.
In means
to be in the middle of something—surrounded by it on all sides. In the story
the cat is trapped under a table in
downpour.
The -
helps take the title a more literally - there is a cat and there is
rain.
Rain
- is ordinary yet fascinating. It invariably alters one’s mood.
Characters
There are only a very few
characters: the wife, husband, the hotel keeper, and the maid. Hemingway does
not describe characters. Their characteristics reveal themselves through what
they do/not do and speech.
The wife:
- While sitting at the window
and looking out at the square, the American wife spots a cat in the
rain.
- She tells her husband that
she's going to go downstairs to get it.
- Downstairs at the hotel, the
wife has a brief exchange with the hotel owner about the rain. We hear
about all the different little things she likes about him. She turns to
go out into the square.
- As she opens the door, a maid
appears with an umbrella and goes out with her.
- They look under the table but
they do not find the cat, and return inside.
- The hotel owner bows from his
desk as the American wife passes. She is filled with a sense of
importance in his presence.
- The American wife returns to
the hotel room where her husband is still reading.
- She sits in front of a
mirror, looks at her profile, and asks if she would look better with
long hair. Her husband tells her she wouldn't, and she begins to talk
about the things she feels she wants: a cat, long hair that she can feel
and twist, candles, silver, and for it to be spring outside.
- The husband tells her to shut
up. She pulls back to one simple desire: she wants a cat.
- As the room grows darker,
there's a knock at the door. It's the maid, and she's holding a cat that
the hotel owner asked her to bring to the wife.
We are told that the
husband and wife are the only Americans in the hotel. We can't be sure why
they're there. Their marriage is on the rocks. The woman is identified as the
“wife”- it is the only identity the woman seems to have. By not naming her,
Hemingway seems to want the reader to take her as a stereotype "American
wife" of 1920s.
Her husband on the other
hand has a name. Not having a name prevents the wife from being a real person
on her own right. She is looked upon as an extension of her husband. While
the husband reads, the wife sits at the window looking out. Her existence seems
to revolve around her husband and house. In Italy she is out of her natural
elements and completely dependent on her husband. Neglected by her husband
who is bent on catching up on his reading on the rainy day, she expresses her
dissatisfaction indirectly by saying that she wanted to rescue a cat. She
seems to draw parallels between her situation and that of the cat in the rain
– she is neglected, bored and miserably out of her element: "It isn't any fun to be a poor kitty
out in the rain." The
idea of rescuing a cat serves two purposes: she wants to draw her husband’s
towards herself and the act of rescuing the cat offers her a temporary sense
of purpose. Upon returning to the room after the unsuccessful rescue mission,
she adds some more items to her wish list: her own silver, candles, and her
own dining table – in short, she seems to want a home of her own. She also
wants long hair, springtime and new clothes. These items are
suggestive of her desire for a change in the state of her marriage for the
better. This in turn points
to the possibility that the wife and her husband at the moment are living a
rootless life which makes the wife feel insecure. The wife seems to crave
stability and security, two things a lot of people lose during times of war. This
is why the wife is fascinated by the hotel owner, the padrone, who is
established, dignified, and serious. She seems to resent the brash American-ness
represented by her husband and herself in favour of the more sophisticated values
of an older and more established Europe represented by the hotel owner. A
"signora" is what the American wife unconsciously wanted to be and
that is exactly how the padrone made her feel like.
George
Unlike the wife, the hotel keeper,
and the maid who are in perpetual motion, George, the husband, is in bed reading
throughout the story. He even suggests that his wife does the same. George
seems to derive satisfaction by reading about the lives recorded in books rather
than by living his own life. He is the antithesis of his wife: static vs.
mobile, intellectual vs. material, insensitive vs. sensitive, self-sufficient
vs. dependent, etc. George says very little throughout the story. The reader
gets an insight to his character through the way he says things, i.e., when
he tells his wife that he would go down for the cat he does not even make an
attempt to get out of the bed. In contrast, the hotel keeper goes out of his
way to acquire a cat for the wife. Therefore, it is natural for the neglected
wife to like "the way he wanted to serve her". The term “serve” has
feudal connotations. The modern American wife finds the old fashioned
gallantry padrone attractive. When his
wife is about to go out in the rain George simply says, “Don't get wet”; whereas
the hotel keeper sends the maid with an umbrella to ensure that she would not
get wet. During the time of the war, with the men absent, a lot of women took
over men’s work out of necessity. Inadvertently, this gave rise to the
Feminist movement. While many women said to have resented returning to their
former state of total dependence, the wife in this story seems to be an
exception. George, probably a upper middleclass neo-liberalist, seems to be
more than happy to let his wife look after herself, both physically and
emotionally. One might ask whether it was his nature that made him so
insensitive or the war, more specifically post-traumatic stress induced by
the war, that made him behave the way he did.
The Hotel Keeper
We hear how the wife "liked
the way he wanted to serve her" and that "she liked the way he felt
about being a hotel keeper." She
seems to project her own desires of what she wants her husband to be on the
hotel keeper. He makes her feel cherished: “Something felt very small and tight inside the girl. The padrone made
her feel very small and at the same time really important. She had a
momentary feeling of being of supreme importance.” It seems that the
wife sees the hotel keeper as a symbol of masculinity. He, being masculine,
makes her feel feminine to the extent that she says to her husband that she
is "tired of looking like a boy." At beginning of the story the
American wife was looking for the reason for her unhappiness. She knew that
she was unhappy but she did not know the why she was unhappy. Her encounter
with the Old World charm of the “padrone” allows her to understand that the
reason for her unhappiness is the dissatisfactory state of her marriage. Her
husband expects her to be a modern woman. She craves attention which is given
to her by the padrone. It is going to be inevitable that in future the wife
is going to compare her husband’s lack of attention to the abundance of
attention showered on her by the hotel keeper.
The cat as a symbol:
There's something in the cat that
the wife both wants and identifies with, which means that it's a symbol that
works in at least two ways. The cat is pitifully isolated and completely out
of its comfort zone. Compare this with the wife's own situation with the
husband. She, too, is a cat in the rain. While the shelter offered by the
café table makes the cat curls up to form a tight ball, it is the care the hotel
keeper offers the neglected wife that makes her feel "small [and] tight."
1. Gender
·
The
wife went downstairs and the hotel owner stood up and bowed to her as she
passed the office.
·
She
liked his big heavy face and big hands.
·
As
the American girl passed the office, the padrone bowed from his desk.
Something felt very small and tight inside the girl.
·
George
looked up and saw the back of her neck, clipped close like a boy's. – This is
how George sees his wife—as boyish – and he approves of it.
·
"I
get so tired of it," she said. "I get so tired of looking like a
boy."
·
"I
want to pull my hair back tight and smooth and make a big knot at the back that
I can feel," she said.
·
"I
want to have a kitty to sit on my lap and purr when I stroke her."
·
"And
I want to eat at a table with my own silver and I want candles."
·
"And
I want it to be spring and I want to brush my hair out in front of a mirror
and I want a kitty and I want some new clothes."
·
"Excuse
me," she said, "the padrone asked me to bring this for the
Signora."
2. Foreignness and the Other
·
“There were only two Americans stopping at the hotel.”
The first sentence tells the
reader that:
1) the story is set in a foreign
country
2) it involves people in transit
and
3) those people are the "others" in this setting. Even though the story is narrated
from the perspective of the Americans, the husband and wife are outsiders.
The American wife’s attraction to the padrone’s foreignness stems from her
frustration with her own way of living.
- Why
does Hemingway make the couple the only Americans at the hotel?
- Why is the
story set in Italy?
- How and why
does Hemingway shift between Italian and English in the dialogue?
- How does the
setting of a hotel bring foreignness specifically to your attention – or
mediate it?
·
They
did not know any of the people they passed on the stairs on their way to and
from their room.
·
Italians
came from a long way off to look up at the war monument. - conveys a sense of
national cohesion in contrast to the distance between the husband and wife.
·
The
American wife stood at the window looking out.
·
"Si,
si, Signora, brutto tempo. It's very bad weather." - The padrone, while acknowledging
the wife’s attempt at speaking in Italian, makes sure that they communicated.
·
When
she talked English the maid's face tightened.
3. Dissatisfaction
Unable to express the reason for
her dissatisfaction, the wife's restlessness increases throughout the story.
- Does Hemingway seem to
sympathize with the wife's dissatisfaction? Or does he, like George,
think that she's just being whiny?
- Does Hemingway signal that
the George is dissatisfied too? How?
- How does Hemingway use the
wife's specific "wants" to describe the source of her
dissatisfaction?
- Do you think that the couple
will stay together? Why or why not?
- In "Cat in the
Rain" Hemingway uses frustrations and desires for material things
to point towards deeper existential dissatisfactions in his characters. The
American wife's restlessness with her restless lifestyle allows
Hemingway to critique the paradox of free-spirited American Bohemians in
the 1920s. Discuss.
The American wife stood at the
window looking out. (2)
"Oh, I wanted it so much. I
wanted a kitty."
"I wanted it so much,"
she said. "I don't know why I wanted it so much. I wanted that poor
kitty." - The wife's desire to "save" the cat from the rain is
replaced by the term "want." Why do you think this is? What is it
about that feeling of holding the cat and owning it that appeals to her? What
does it have in common with the other things she wants?
"It isn't any fun to be a
poor kitty out in the rain."
She studied her profile, first one
side and then the other. - the boredom or satisfaction of her life rests on
more than her hairstyle. So why does she attach her sense of satisfaction to
these things here? Why does she express her discontentment this way?
"I get so tired of it,"
she said. "I get so tired of looking like a boy." - there is
something draining about this boyish appearance. It's something she has to
keep up, and something that's not very "fun."
"Oh, shut up and get something
to read," George said.
He was reading again. His wife was
looking out the window. – the use of past continuous suggests that locked up
in their own worlds the husband and wife aren't really paying attention to
what the other just said.
George was not listening. He was
reading his book. – use of the continuous form here suggests that this sort
of inattentiveness has happened in other "discussions" before.
4. Isolation
Like the cat in the rain, the wife
and the husband are not only alone they are also trapped in their own worlds.
Their isolation is reinforced by the discomfort of their feelings towards
each other. There is a serious lack of real communication.
- Why can't the husband and
wife communicate?
- Why does the wife think that
a cat will help her to feel less isolated?
- Why is reading an
insufficient solution for the loneliness felt by the wife?
- Why does the padrone, specifically,
make the wife feel less alone and insignificant than before?
- The wife might feel that a
different lifestyle will solve her isolation, but Hemingway shows in
this story that it is a deeper problem of attitude and communication
that plagues her. Discuss.
- The "very small and
tight" feeling that the girl has before the padrone, as well as her
"feeling of being of supreme importance" in that moment,
offers sexual re-awakening as a possible solution to the problem of
isolation. Discuss
·
There
were only two Americans stopping at the hotel.
·
Outside
right under their window a cat was crouched under one of the dripping green
tables.
·
When
she talked English the maid's face tightened.
·
She
had a momentary feeling of being of supreme importance.
·
George
was reading again.
·
"I
want to have a kitty to sit on my lap and purr when I stroke her."
|