Saturday, December 9, 2023

Twilight of a Crane: 1. By referring to the text, compare and contrast the characters of Tsu and Yohyo in Twilight of a Crane

 


·       Character arc – what does the character look like at beginning and at the end

·       what are the changes, what had made the changes,

·       how had the changes affected the characters and those around him.

·       What is the thematic relevance of the change the character undergoes

·       How do the interactions between the two characters highlight the themes of the play

In this answer, I will be dealing with two character arcs: the character arc of Tsu and that of Yohyo. In the course of the answer I will be dealing with how the two characters looked at the beginning and the end; what are the changes the two characters have undergone; what caused those changes in them; what are the thematic relevance of the changes and how the interactions between the characters highlight the themes of the play.

Let us look at the character arc of Tsu first. Initially, the audience come across Tsu as Yohyo’s wife. She is a stranger to the village. According to Unzu, after her arrival, Yohyo spends all his life just relaxing by the fire doing nothing. Sodo wonders how Yohyo managed to make such a pretty woman his wife. Towards the middle of the play we learn that Tsu was a crane that had metamorphed into a woman out of gratitude to Yohyo for saving her life. According to Yohyo she comes to his door one night and offers to be his wife. At this point, thematically speaking, Tsu represents natural forces and positive traits such as kindness, love and self-sacrifice.

As a wife, Tsu loved her husband very much, wanted to make him happy even at the expense her own life and health. She overlooks Yohyo’s laziness and the fact that he was a very bad provider, his fascination with hoarding money and his inability to value the gifts of senba ori. She single mindedly focuses on his only good quality: his kindness towards her at a time she was injured and his occasional displays of concern for comfort. For Tsu, one’s word was important; ultimately, she leaves Yohyo because he breaks his promise to her not to look at her while she was weaving. In contrast to her relationship with Yohyo which is primarily based on gratitude, Tsu’s relationship with the children is based on their shared desire to live a life close to nature and enjoy the moment. Tsu’s character stands for the theme of positive aspects of nature. Her interactions and the final outcome of the interactions stand for the interactions between nature and capitalism.

Tsu as a character of nature, likes to lead an uncomplicated life. She urges Yohyo to give up his desire to visit Kyoto and live happily with her in the rural area where they lived forever. Yohyo makes references to Tsu having seen Kyoto several times. What Tsu may have seen in Kyoto makes her reluctant to go there even to keep her husband by her side. Kyoto frightens her.  To her, Kyoto represented everything complicated and corrupt. She is frightened by Yohyo’s fascination with the capital city and believes once he gets there he would not return to her. What happens to Tsu in the end is a warning to the audience as to what could be the final outcome of a conflict between the benevolent aspects of nature and capitalism. After all the upheaval, even at the end of the play she remains true to her character; she does not change much in the course of the play. Tsu’s character arc is almost linear. Tsu is aware of the human potential for evil: she had seen corruption in Kyoto and she had been the victim of human cruelty – she had been shot at with an arrow. But, she is willing to believe that human beings are capable of finer feelings such as generosity, love, kindness and appreciation of beauty. Also, Tsu as a wife, represent values such as self-sacrifice and honour promoted by feudal Japan.

Secondly, let us look at the character of Yohyo. According to the script, Yohyo is one of the protagonists in the drama. He is young farmer from rural area. He is unsophisticated: both Unzu and Sodo consider Yohyo to be foolish and they easily manipulate him to do their bidding. Yohyo lacks a strong willpower. Therefore, anyone with a strong personality can change the way he thought and behaved. If we were to consider Tsu as a representation of nature and Unzu and Sodo as personifications of capitalism, Yohyo is the weak man caught between two powerful forces. 

Before meeting Tsu, Yohyo must have supported himself through his farming activities, but after meeting Tsu he does not seem to be doing any work: the house is a tumbled down hut. It has not been made ready to meet the brutal Japanese winters. The farm lays fallow and there are no references to granaries or stored food. Instead of supporting his wife, he becomes a lazy man who lay sleeping by the fireside who is supported by the efforts of his wife.  Tsu tries to convey her love and gratitude by weaving a Senba Ori for him. Yohyo is incapable of understanding the significance of the cloth; therefore, instead of treasuring it he sells it and hoards money in sacks. Tsu wants be happy with Yohyo, but Yohyo wants to earn a lot of money. Yohyo is depend on Tsu’s weaving. It is his shortsightedness that exposes their relationship to Unzu and Sodo who callously exploits Yohyo’s weaknesses to their advantage. In summary, when we look at the development arc of Yohyo’s character, the Yohyo we see until the very end is predominantly driven by his fascination with money and the desire to please his senses. Still, he is not a complete monochromatic character: there is both good and bad in him. He is a weak and lazy man who puts his desires above that of his wife. However, he is also capable of acts of kindness towards both Tsu and the children who come to play with them. .   

In conclusion, let us summarize how the two characters looked at the beginning and the end; what are the changes the two characters have undergone; what caused those changes in them; what are the thematic relevance of the changes and how the interactions between the characters highlight the themes of the play.

Out of the two main characters, we meet Tsu and Yohyo as mature people who are more or less set in their way. The character arc of the male is almost nonexistent. The male protagonist we see at the beginning is more or less the same person we would see at the end. Tsu’s character, on the other hand, …

No comments:

Post a Comment

The “humour” poems in our syllabus while providing humour, attempt to convey some greater truths. Discuss this statement with relevance to three poems in your syllabus:

  The term “humour” is often associated with silliness, meaninglessness, lack of depth, etc. Therefore, when a poem receives the “appellatio...